РефератыИностранный языкAnAnalysis Of Women In The Military Essay

Analysis Of Women In The Military Essay

, Research Paper


Women have been compared to the frailty and beauty of ripe


apricots in modern poetry; the reference could be construed as sexual.


However, in spite of their frailty and beauty, women have served in


combat positions in one capacity or another since the beginning of the


United States, long before the establishment of the Army Nurse Corps


in 1901. Many women willingly entered the pits of battle, disguised


as men and using male names in past wars. With growing numbers of


women in the military and their roles in Desert Storm, the Persian


Gulf War, Somalia, and Bosnia, there is increasing interest regarding


their full integration and future role in combat. There are still US


military women who strive to be allowed to serve their country in


other capacities during war time since the first deployment of women


on combat ships in 1995.


Most people have trust in their armed services to protect and


uphold the ideals in which their country was founded. Allowing women


to enter the armed forces represented the ideal that everyone should


have equal opportunities to pursue happiness. Within this silver


lining there is the contention by some that in letting women serve,


especially in a direct combat role, we are defeating the primary


purpose of the military: to protect our mother country. This view


could be considered to fall in unison with the ancient double standard


that women are the weaker gender. But what is combat specifically?


Combat is about being exhausted, hungry, and living in the mud for


long periods without access to clean water for drinking or bathing.


It?s about long periods of boredom interrupted by violent interludes


of jolting fear, mingled with the agonizing cries of wounded, and the


piercing sound of artillery. It?s about the flesh burning stench from


napalm or watching as fellow comrades gasp a last breath. It?s about


extreme discomfort and random degrees of emotion coursing through your


being with no way out. Women in military specialties that are closer


to the action would result in the likelihood of their becoming


casualties just like men. Does this relevant factor elude those who


want to be in combat? During Desert Storm five women were killed by


hostile action, while two were held captive.


Some women in the military maintain that service in combat


means more promotions for them; thereby attracting more women to the


service. Has combat been reduced to an opportunity? Does this


contingency sound similar to the propaganda and glorification of war


arranged to intrigue the naive into conflict? Surveys claim that some


military women do not think of war as such. A 1992 survey concerning


differences among Army personnel found that only 12 percent of Army


enlisted women would volunteer for combat arms if it were at all


possible. Critics claim physical standards for combat training are at


risk and will be compromised if women are allowed into combat


positions. Physical standards are critically important in such


occupations as the infantry and in special operations units. There is


>

contention regarding the disruption of the military?s mission when


female troops allowed in combat


become pregnant. It is thought by some, the relationships that would


inevitably develop would induce new and greater risk for men who acted


differently in combat toward females than they do toward males.


Homosexuality in the military offers additional biased credence to


this theory.


But the most damaging instance is thought to be the


devastating impact on the morale, team cohesion, and fighting spirit


within the armed forces. Combat is known to be a team activity which


regiments soldiers. Some women may indeed be as physically and


mentally capable as men to perform combat duties, but what matters


more in combat is not so much individual ability as teamwork. It is


presumed the presence of women in combat would disrupt the basic


teamwork that makes a difference between victory and defeat or life


and death on the battlefield.


And finally, there is the rising of the old argument that


female soldiers will be taken prisoner and sexually abused by enemy


forces. Major Rhonda Cornum who was taken prisoner by Iraqi forces


after her helicopter was shot down over Iraq during the Persian Gulf


War denied any abuse initially, however she later admitted that she


was ?violated manually vaginally and rectally.? How many men taken


prisoner denied any abuse when they were subjected to sexual


violations? Under any conditions, in our society males are reluctant


to admit or volunteer information of this type of abuse when they are


the victim. Further, from the experience in Desert Storm, sexual


abuse of female captives will undoubtedly be used to extort


information from male prisoners. History has proven that despite the


Geneva Convention, varying degrees of mistreatment is always practiced


to extort information.


The role of women in the military will continue to be a topic


of discussion whether the issue is combat, family, or homosexuality.


The acceptance of women in the armed forces has been evolving from a


role of freeing men for combat to equality in all facets of military


life. Today, women are undergoing training as combat pilots and crew


members for aircraft carriers and other fighting ships. This change


is in response to demands for the potential of career advancement and


equal opportunities for women who are qualified and truly want to


serve in dangerous combat jobs. When a female soldier may choose


whether or not she goes into combat, this creates a reversed meaning


for the old term double standard; There is no option for the male


soldiery.


Desert Storm commander General Norman Schwarzkopf testified to


Congress, ?Decisions on what roles women should play in war must be


based on military standards, not women?s rights.? Applying the


individuals make the team analogy of critics, let me suggest the


military standard should not center on anyone?s rights or obligation,


but instead on the individual in all instances. Perhaps then war would


be called off like other events that lack participation.

Сохранить в соц. сетях:
Обсуждение:
comments powered by Disqus

Название реферата: Analysis Of Women In The Military Essay

Слов:1094
Символов:7414
Размер:14.48 Кб.