Does Imperialism Really Work? Essay, Research Paper
Period 3 Novermber 9, 2000
Does Imperialism Really Work?
Imperialism is a policy by a stronger nation to create an empire by
dominating weaker nations economically, politically, culturally, or militarily. It
doesn’t work for the most part. It strains relations between countries and generally
creates bad feelings. Almost every time the United States got involved in a foreign
place it caused trouble. The main times that strained relations occurred were
durring the late eighteen hundreds in Latin America and the far east. Hawaii, for
example, was annexed when the government that was in place there was working
perfectly fine. The Filipino people rebeled against the United States forces when
they became a territory of the U.S. Cuba was helped toward independence by the
U.S., but they also put an amendment in their constitution that limited their trade
and involvement with countries other than the U.S. very greatly. I agree with the
statement “Imperialism usually causes strained relations between the countries
involved.”
The United States involvment in Hawaii was definetely an example of
imperialism causing strained relations. The original reason that the U.S. got
involved with Hawaii was for trade. They were also leasing Pearl Harbor from
them as a naval fueling station. The king of Hawaii was forced to sign a revised
constitution that essentially gave the U.S. control of Hawaii. In 1891 his sister
came to power. She opposed U.S. control in Hawaii and because of this was
removed from power. Shortly after this Hawaii was annexed by the United States
with little thought to how the natives felt or whether they could govern themselves.
The Hawaii annexation is a good example of strained relations caused by
imperialism.
The Phillipines also didn’t respond well to American imperialism. When
the U.S. bought the Philipines from Spain at the end of the Spanish-American war,
they justified themselves by saying that the Filipino people were unfit to govern
themselves. They also said tha
have. When the Filipinos found out about this they felt that they had been stabbed
in the back. They had fought with the American troops against Spain durring the
Spanish-American War expecting to get independence in the end. Now they had a
new owner instead. A vicious war broke out between the U.S. and the Philipines
that lasted over three years. That would be a definite example of strained relations.
America’s involvement in Cuba was also not as friendly as most would have
liked for it to be. After Cuba had been having problems with Spain for a while,
America got involved to protect their trade interest. After the Spainsh-American
War got it’s independence, but because of the chaotic environment at the time,
President McKinley installed a military government there. It remained there for
three years. When the Cuban government finally did start to draft a constitution
the U.S. made them include a bunch of provisions outlined in the Platt
Amendment. The provisions included not letting the Cuban government enter in
any foreign agreements, Cuba must allow the U.S. to have two naval bases on the
island, and Cuba had to give America the right to intervene whenever they felt it
was necessary. All of these things couldn’t help but cause some strained relations
between Cuba and the U.S.
The statement “Imperialism usually causes strained relations between the
countries involved” is definitely true. America’s involvement in the far east and
Latin America are good examples of this. When the U.S. annexed Hawaii they did
it without even consdering the well being of the natives of the islands. The
Philipines was expecting independence when they helped America in the Spanish-
American War, but instead they got a new owner. Cuba was helped toward its
independence by the U.S. but then the Platt Amendment was added to their
constitution limiting their contact with countries other than America. Any one of
these things would be enough to get on a person’s nerves. For the most part
nothing good comes from imperialism.