Prostitution Essay, Research Paper
Prostitution:
Effects of New Legislation on the Oldest Profession
Sex for sell. For some prostitution is a victimless crime while others
fight hard in the hopes of one day abolishing prostitution forever. The
topic of prostitution remains a greatly debated issue even after so many
years of existence. Prostitution existed as far back in time as ancient
Athens and ancient Rome. In Rome, prostitutes were licensed by the state
and
taxed. Prostitution continued to flourished through out Europe until the
High Middle Ages with the outbreak of the syphilis epidemic and Reformation
morality (Academic American Encyclopedia 91). In most large Western cities
today prostitution is illegal but tolerated, because police there are more
concerned with regulating the crimes, organized by crime syndicates,
associated with prostitution (Compton’s Interactive Encyclopedia 94). Other
Western governments combine regulated prostitution with public health
measures to control disease (American Academic Encyclopedia 91).
Prostitution has lasted and survived every attack by civilization to end
it.
Some would say that for as long people have both money and sexual
frustration some will continue to pay others to satisfy them ( Bovard 18).
Existing throughout the world and time, prostitution has managed to
survive,
however a growing number of people are beginning to look at the effect
legalization of or strict laws for prostitution would have on a community.
Prostitution in the world is alive and well despite the fact that is it
consider
illegal in most developed countries (Academic American Encyclopedia 91).
Some see it as an issue of safety in out neighborhoods and other take it on
as a moral issue. However, because of the spread of disease and what seems
to be a futile battle, many cities in America and other countries are
considering the possibility of legalization and regulation of prostitution.
In Britain, it is considered legal to sell sex but, the associated
activities including soliciting, advertising, street walking, and running
brothels is illegal (”Green-light areas” 73). The article “Green-Light
Area”
talks of how the police in Britain tend to turn a blind eye to prostitution
and go after the pimps and drug-dealers who are connected with the
prostitution (73).This method of policing is different from that in America
where police concentrate on the prostitutes themselves. Brothels are also
given license in Britain. The thinking being that is it allows regular
visits by health officials who check basic standards of hygiene and can
dispose of dirty needles (”Green-Light Area” 73). Canada has similar laws
pertaining to prostitution. The selling of sex is legal, but pimping and
working a brothel is illegal (World Sex Guide 96). Toronto would like to
license prostitutes and relocate to official red-light district. The plan
has little support and most of its critics say it will be ineffectual
(Chisholm 35). Vancouver also has a program that allows streetwalkers to
their jobs uninterrupted as long as they stay outside so called “no-go”
neighborhoods (Chisholm 35). The solution for several countries and cities
who have high levels of prostitution seems to be to open red light
districts. In fact, some cities around the world have already taken that
step. Critics would argue that this is a sort of give up mentality.
Hamburg and Amsterdam are such places that have taken that step. These
places are often cited as models that provide safer environments for
prostitutes. Some would argue that the benefits to red-light districts as
those in Hamburg and Amsterdam are limited because the successful
prostitutes would dominate these zones and others would simply move to
surrounding neighborhoods (Chisholm 35). Hamburg is noted for making
streetwalkers undergo frequent health checks but even advocates for the
legalization of prostitution say that Amsterdam has some problems t
out (Bovard 18). The most known about place for commercial sex in America
is
the state of Nevada. Brothels, which are legal in 12 rural counties in
Nevada tend to be safe places to indulge in sexual activities. (Bovard 18).
Those against prostitution state that although the brothels may be not a
health risk there still are downfalls. Anastasia Volkonsky, a columnist for
Insight on the News, says that even the legal brothels maintain a
connection
with the pimping circuit by paying finder’s fee to pimps who discover and
bring in new girls (20). Women in Nevada’s brothels have reported working
12
hour shifts even menstruating or pregnant, right to refuse a customer’s
sexual demands. (Volkonsky 20). In places such as Budapest, no only is
prostitution legal but is flourishing and now the government wants to tax
it. The average prostitute in Hungary makes around two-thousand dollars a
month. Brothels will probably be allow soon and the only major restriction
is that soliciting is banned near churches and schools. (”The Red Lights of
Italy…and Hungary” 45). Not all places like the if you cannot be them
join
them attitude taken by many countries and cities. They believe the best way
to stop prostitution is through harsher laws that target certain
individuals
and tough enforcement.
Those who want stronger laws against prostitution now want to concentrate
more on the customer more so than the prostitute. Many officials advocate
crackdowns on johns and pimps while providing help for those women who
want
to leave the life of prostitution (Chisholm 35).
One could argue that as far as crimes go prostitution is victimless crime,
but others would say that it is a matter of public safety and disease
control. Would harsher laws end prostitution or result in a lot of persons
getting their cars impounded? Regardless as to what effects harsher laws
will have on prostitution, new laws are still being tried out in several
states in America. Advocates for legalization say that harsher laws have to
be enforced and that cost money. One Los Angeles official estimated that
prostitution enforcement was costing the city more than 100 million a year
(Bovard 18). Still the trend in America seems to lean toward legislation to
crackdown on prostitution. Supporters feel that targeting the customer
kills
the demand in an area and so the prostitutes are forced to move to another
area. Some ways police enforce these laws are to extreme say some critics
of
harsher legislation.
In most cases, since neither prostitutes nor their clients complain to
police out the others conduct, law enforcement rely sting operations to
catch offenders ( Bovard 18). In the past these sting operation would give
the offender a minor punishment and send them on their way. Today law
enforcement is beginning to see that it is the customer with their jobs,
money, status in society, clean arrest record, and anonymity that have the
most to lose. This has triggered laws that allows police to seize cars
those
soliciting prostitutes( Volkonsky 20). Another popular new legal step taken
to shame would-be customers, is to list their name or photo in the town
paper.( Volkonsky 20). These new measure may or may not work, it is still
to
soon to tell. Prostitution has started to get more and more attention in
the
last year or so and change in legislation is almost inevitable.
Although change is coming, the world is still divided on where, what, and
when the change is coming. Advocates for legalization believe red-light
districts and regulation is the answer. Others believe new laws that target
and effect would be offenders is the answer. No one can predict the future
and only time will tell. Tomorrow may bring a country that is similar to
Nevada or a place where convicted offenders have their vehicles impounded
and there faces shown on the local news.
31f