Cloning Good Or Bad Essay Research

Cloning. Good Or Bad Essay, Research Paper

Cloning: Good or Bad

The rapid development of the technology for cloning has led to moral debates

around the world on whether or not to ban breathing human clones. While the potential

benefits of genetic engineering are considerable, so may be the potential dangers. We

have come to believe that all human beings are equal, but even more firmly, we are

taught to believe each one of us is unique. Is that idea undercut by cloning? That is, if

you can deliberately make any number of copies of an individual, is each one special?

Cloning could provide a way for infertile couples to produce children genetically similar

to themselves. Human cloning may provide numerous benefits to mankind. This is the

new world of cloning, and thanks to a 7-month-old sheep named Dolly, a new science has

been born. As with every new science, there are those who believe in it, and those who

oppose it. In the two articles that are covered in this paper, the first one, BBC NEWS:

Public Express Concern Over Cloning, is against cloning and the second article, THE

NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE: Should Human Cloning Research Be Off

Limits, supports cloning. By reviewing the articles, they will tell the audience which has

a better claim by how well it s written.

The first article talks about the negatives of cloning, but doesn t back up the

information. For example, The survey found virtually no support for cloning for

reproductive purposes, even in those groups which might have been expected to be

sympathetic, such as infertile couples . (BBC NEWS, p.1) This article basically is just

stating how segments of the population feels about cloning and not backing it up with

data and other forms of evidence. Throughout the whole article, evidence is very hard to

find. It sounds like the editor felt that everyone knew what was going on in cloning and

not explaining in detail and backing up those claims from people.

The editor did not really have a strong thesis and did not have good rhetoric.

This article brings up the point that many do not agree with the use of cloning for human

purpose in order for parents to choose their child. The article should have gone further

and written up some more information such as, by reproducing characteristics that

parents desire would foul-up the diversity of society. If everyone was able to choose

what characteristics his or her child would have, most people would opt for the

characteristics of famous people who are either extremely smart or who are incredibly

good looking. The generation of the clone people would be so similar in ways of

thinking and in personality that the world would become a very boring place, if that were

the case. The replication and copying of DNA can cause damage to the genetic code. In

this case, it is possible for genetic disorders arise. If a sample of DNA is taken from a

younger person to copy, that person could be carrying a code for some sort of disorder

whose symptoms would not show until later in the person s life. Therefore, the exact

code that would be copied to make another human carries that disorder. There are many

things that need to be sorted out such as who can use cloning and how it will be