, Research Paper
Colonization in the Theme of "A Modest Proposal" and "Heart of
Darkness" Starting at the beginning of the seventeenth century, European
countries began exploring and colonizing many different areas of the world. The
last half of the nineteenth century saw the height of European colonial power
around the globe. France, Belgium, Germany, and especially Great Britain,
controlled over half the world. Along with this achievement came a notable sense
of pride and confident belief that European civilization was the best on earth
and that the natives of the lands Europeans controlled would only benefit from
colonial influence. However, not everybody saw colonization as positive for all
those involved. Some of the most notable writers of the time produced works
criticizing the process of colonization. Two of the most significant works in
this area are Joseph Conrad?s "Heart of Darkness" and Jonathan
Swift?s "A Modest Proposal." Although these pieces of literature
both criticize colonization, they have different themes. The theme of "A
Modest Proposal" could be described as the negative effects of colonization
on the colonized, while the central idea in "Heart of Darkness" is the
negative effects of colonization on both the colonized and the colonizers. The
differences in these themes are significant to the strategies used by the
authors to explore the adverse effects of colonization. Swift makes great use of
irony and imagery, to accentuate the plight of the Irish. Conrad comments on the
frightening changes that people involved with colonization can go through by
exploring character development and detailing a narrative of oppression. Swift
uses irony in "A Modest Proposal" because it allows him to highlight
the emotional detachment felt by the colonizing British towards the Irish. It is
this emotional detached feeling that lead to the atrocities committed against
the Irish citizens. The irony in "A Modest Proposal" is evident right
in the title. There is certainly nothing "modest" about the
"proposal" of eating the infants of impoverished Irish citizens. The
irony accentuates how cruel and uncompassionate the powerful British
Imperialists were, towards the destitute Irish population. The reader must
realize that "Swift is operating independently of the narrator in a covert
manner" (Phiddian 607). He develops the persona of the proposer to say
exactly the opposite of what he feels. While the proposer suggests eating poor
Irish children is particularly proper at "merry meetings, particularly
weddings and christenings," this could not be further from the opinion of
Swift. Nor does Swift actually believe that this plan will "increase the
care and tenderness of mothers toward their children." (NA 1052) Moreover,
the whole topic of cannibalism, is discussed with tongue in cheek and is meant
to suggest that the British were devouring the Irish. Images of cruelty and evil
put, forward by the narrator, weigh heavily in the theme of "A Modest
Proposal." Throughout the pamphlet, the reader is bombarded with disturbing
imagery of Irish people and their children being treated like livestock raised
for consumption. The narrator refers to the parents of the children as
"savages" (NA 1050) and "breeders" (NA 1051) and
"dams" (NA 1048). Then he compares the children to "roasting
pigs" (NA 1050) and continues as if he were writing a cook book. He speaks
of how delicious he thinks these infants would be "whether stewed, roasted,
baked or boiled" (NA 1049) or served in a "fricassee or a ragout"
(NA 1049). He describes how the "carcasses" (NA 1050) of these babies
could be nicely seasoned with "a little pepper or salt" (NA 1050) and
"will be in season throughout the year" (NA 1050). Flaying the carcass
and using the skin of these babies to make "admirable gloves for ladies,
and summer boots for fine gentlemen" (NA 1050) is another suggestion he
puts forward. He expands beyond just slaughtering the infants for food and
leather products by suggesting the possibility of hunting the adolescents for
sport. He dismisses this idea because he imagines the flesh of the adolescents
would be too tough for eating and because hunting them would reduce the breeding
stock. He also has concerns that "some scrupulous people might be apt to
censure such a practice (although indeed very unjustly) as a little bordering on
cruelty" (NA 1051). All of the gruesome imagery used in "A Modest
Proposal" has earned it the reputation of being one of Swift?s most
potent attacks in his "war on a class of civilized people who often behave
like animals" (McMinn 149). Joseph Conrad details a narrative of oppression
emphasizing the horrible treatment of African natives during the colonization of
the Congo. The Europeans claimed that they were trying to civilize the natives,
and that each colonized station should be for "humanizing, improving and
instructing," (NA 2228) as if colonization was to the advantage of the
natives. In the same voice, it was said that the natives were "brutes"
(NA 2242) and "savages" (NA 2218) and that they should all be
"exterminated" (NA 2242). "Heart of Darkness" described
African blacks as being "criminals" (NA 2216) and "enemies"
(NA 2214) and they were treated as such. The natives were forced to do intense
heavy labor for the colonizers. They dug holes, tunneled through mountains,
moved soil from one place to another in baskets balanced on their heads. When
there was no meaningful work needed to be done, the blacks were forced
heavy labor just for the sake of doing heavy labor. They did "objectless
blasting" (NA 2215) and other pointless work in the whites
"philanthropic desire of giving the criminals something to do" (NA
2216). They were treated like working animals. They were forced to carry 60lb
loads 200 miles in scorching heat with inadequate nourishment. A number of them
died on that trip. In the stations they worked in chain gangs where, "each
had an iron collar on his neck, and all were connected with a chain" (NA
2215). They were supervised by other gun wielding natives who had apparently
joined the colonizers in the oppression of their people. When the overworked
natives could work no more they would simply crawl under a tree in the shade and
die. If the blacks stopped working, made a mistake, or were suspected of making
a mistake, they were beaten savagely. Beatings are very common in "Heart of
Darkness." The European pilgrims are constantly in the possession of
staves, just in case they should have to discipline a native. A black man was
beaten nearly to death as the result of a dispute over two hens. Then later in
the story, a black man was beaten so badly that after a few days he just
wandered off into the forest and died. It becomes increasingly clear as the plot
develops that the colonizing Europeans treated the land and the people they were
colonizing with no respect at all. Through the presentation of characters and
their development through the story, Conrad examines the negative effects
colonization can have on the colonizers. "It makes them lazy; it reveals
their weaknesses; it puffs them up with empty vanity of being white; and it
fortifies the intolerable hypocrisy with which Europeans in general conceal
their selfish aims" (Watt 37). It causes them to hate and brings out the
evil from within them. The first white man that Marlow comes across in the Congo
is the companies accountant. His vanity is evident, from the way he keeps
himself impeccably groomed, while other human beings around him are living
squalid, unbearable lives and dying horrifying deaths. He wore "a high
starched collar, white cuffs, a light alpaca jacket, snowy trousers, a clear
necktie and varnished boots" (NA 2217). Meanwhile, "everything else in
the station was a muddle" (NA 2217) and there were people breathing their
last breaths just outside his door. The development of his hatred while in
Africa is clear when he tells Marlow that "one comes to hate those savages
- hate them to death" (NA 2218). His evilness is accentuated by the flies
that "buzzed fiendishly" (NA 2217) around him, conjuring up images of
Beelzebub, "Lord of the Flies." Though his character is a minor one,
the accountant gives the readers their first taste of the Congo?s detrimental
effects on the colonizers. Kurtz and Marlow are sort of mirror images of one
another. Marlow is what Kurtz once was and Kurtz is what Marlow could have been.
Both are affected adversely by their experience in the Congo. The change in
Marlow is very evident by the end of the story. Near the beginning of the story,
he states that he is appalled by lies, that there is a "taint of
death" (NA 2224) and a "flavour of mortality" (NA 2224) in them.
He says lies are "exactly what I hate and detest in the world – what I want
to forget" (NA 2224). Then in the end of the story, he must make a decision
whether to tell Kurtz?s wife a truth that will devastate her or a lie that
will put her at ease. He lies to her. It may be good intentions that caused him
to lie, but he lied all the same. A part of Marlow died in the Congo and he
became what he hates, a liar. Kurtz on the other hand went into the Congo as a
highly respected person for whom superiors had high hopes and big plans. By the
end of the story Kurtz has gone insane. While Marlow "peeped over the
edge," (NA 2257) and "drew back [his] hesitating foot," (NA 2258)
Kurtz had "made that last stride, he had stepped over the edge" (NA
2258). Kurtz was so damaged by his Congo colonization experience that it killed
him before he made it back to civilization. It is these changes in the main
characters of the story that are most influential in developing, in the reader,
a sense of how colonization effects the colonizer. Colonization is a part of the
theme in both Joseph Conrad?s "Heart of Darkness" and Jonathan
Swift?s "A Modest Proposal." While Swift?s work deals mainly with
the negative effects of colonization on those being colonized, Conrad?s story
explores the negative experiences of both the colonized and the colonizers. The
differences in these themes are significant to the strategies used by the
authors to explore the negative effects of colonization. As in much of his
literary work, Swift uses a great deal of irony and imagery to drive his point
home. Conrad on the other hand, details a narrative of oppression and delves
into character development to describe his thoughts and experiences with
colonization in Africa. These works can be viewed as criticisms of events of the
past, but they should also be viewed as warnings for the future. People should
learn from the past and not make the same mistakes twice. Unfortunately it seems
as if history repeats itself and human beings make the same error over and over
again.
McMinn, Joseph. Jonathan Swift: a literary life. New York: St. Martin?s
Press. 1991. Phiddian, Robert. "Have you eaten yet? The Reader in A Modest
Proposal." SEL: Studies in English Literature (Summer 1996) : 603-621.
Watt, Ian. "Ideological Perspectives: Kurtz and the Fate of Victorian
Progress." Joseph Conrad. Ed. Elaine Jordan. London: Macmillan Press. 1996.